Healthcare ‘not a hierarchy’: Jackson

A GP has written about collaboration with pharmacists, but also refers to the “ceaseless ambition of some pharmacist groups” for prescribing rights and service provision

Dr Richard Kidd, Chair of the AMA Council of General Practice, has written an article about teamwork in healthcare entitled ‘Collaboration, not competition’ for Australian Medicine, while specifically referring to the roles of GPs and pharmacists.

While Dr Kidd praises pharmacists as “vital to the safe provision and use of medicines”, he also shares concerns about fragmented care as pharmacists extend their service provision.

“We all know the dangers to our patients of poorly coordinated, fragmented care. We also know that best practice care starts with the right assessment and diagnosis by a medical practitioner and, in the case of general practice, a longitudinal relationship with the patient,” he writes.

“Despite this, we see ceaseless ambition of some pharmacist groups for prescribing rights and a greater role in the provision of health services, such as preventative health, disease screening and detection and chronic disease management.”

Dr Kidd emphasises that AMA places a high value on the professional role of pharmacists working with medical practitioners and patients to: ensure medication adherence; improve medication management; and provide education about patient safety.

“The AMA fully supports pharmacists undertaking roles within their scope of practices to support patient health care. But the community needs a clear understanding of how the core education and training differentiates medical practitioner and pharmacist scopes of practice.

“Taking comprehensive histories, undertaking examinations, determining appropriate diagnostic investigations, making a diagnosis, and managing and treating a patient are the domain of the medical profession because that is what we, not pharmacists, are trained to do.

“What GPs and pharmacists should do is continue to work together respectfully, acknowledging the different skills and expertise we bring to the team for the patient. Our patients deserve collaboration, not competition, and policy makers must continue to avoid simplistic ideas that are driven by commercial needs and not good patient care.”

PSA national president Shane Jackson says that while he acknowledges the intent of Dr Kidd’s article, it isn’t up to GPs to define the role of pharmacists in healthcare.

“Pharmacists are autonomous health professionals. Our scope is defined by professional standards and training, not by another health professional group,” says Dr Jackson.

“Whilst I acknowledge the intent of Dr Kidd’s article, the continued reference to pharmacist training by individuals and organisations who – to be frank – have little idea of what pharmacist training is, is not helpful to collaboration.

“I have a standing invitation to the AMA to accompany me on a visit to a pharmacy school so they can see the extent of pharmacist education.

“I commend Dr Kidd on wanting better collaboration, but this is not a hierarchy. Pharmacists are autonomous and must be better utilised to protect patients from inappropriate medication use.”

Previous Can we get the numbers right?
Next Clinical tips: insomnia

NOTICE: It can sometimes take awhile for comment submissions to go through, please be patient.

1 Comment

  1. Paige

    I’m sorry Dr. Kidd. But if you’d met half your members you’d know they aren’t nearly as thorough as you think they are. Their disregard over public health outcomes was made very clear by their misguided stance on pharmacist vaccination. Custodians of the public health quickly became custodians of their bank accounts.

Leave a reply